Beard & Belly and Honeypie Bake Shop Online Ordering Menu

100% of 22 customers recommended

Start your carryout or delivery order.

Check Availability

Snacks & Such

Spicy Pickled Egg

Spicy pickled egg topped with remoulade, bacon, and herbs

$2.00+

Chips and Onion Dip

House made crispy potato chips, served with our housemade Onion Dip.

$5.00

Deep-fried Pickles

Thick cut pickle chips, deep fried in our special beer batter, using Dovetail's Vienna lager. Served with our housemade spicy remoulade.

$7.00

Deep Fried Cheese Curds

Wisconsin cheese curds, deep fried in our special beer batter, using Dovetail's Vienna lager. Served with our housemade ranch.

$9.00

Dozen Eggs

One dozen of our spicy eggs sitting in hot sauce for your enjoyment. Served with a ramekin of remoulade and a ramekin of chopped bacon if you want to dress them up like we do.

$20.00

Burgers

Served with chips and choice of sauce. ***Beyond Burgers now available as a vegetarian option, and can also be made VEGAN simply by clicking the "Make it Vegan" option!***

The Half Pint

5oz patty with Butterkäse(it's cheese), pickles, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$10.00+

The Burger*

Two 4oz patties with Butterkäse(it's cheese), pickles, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$14.00+

The Patty Melt

5oz patty with Swiss cheese and caramelized onions on marble rye. Served with a side of ketchup, as is required by patty melt law.

$12.00+

The Belly's Burger

5oz patty with Butterkäse(it's cheese), roasted serrano, pickles, onion jam, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$12.00+

The Beyond 1/2 Pint

5oz BEYOND burger patty with Butterkäse (it's cheese), pickles, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$12.00+

The Beyond Burger

Two 4oz BEYOND burger patties with Butterkäse (it's cheese), pickles, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$18.00+

The Beyond Belly's Burger

5oz BEYOND burger patty with Butterkäse (it's cheese), roasted Serrano peppers, pickles, onion jam, and awesome sauce, served on a potato bun.

$14.00+

The Beyond Patty Melt

5oz BEYOND burger patty smothered in Swiss cheese and caramelized onions on marble rye. Served with a side of ketchup for dipping, as is required by patty melt law.

$14.00+

Sandwiches

Comes with chips and choice of sauce.

Ubiquitous Grilled Cheese

Brioche, Butterkäse(it's cheese), 2-year cheddar(also cheese), and tomato jam.

$10.00+

Fried Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, with bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, Swiss cheese, and RANCH!

$13.00+

Pulled Pork Pull-apart

Our unique pull-aparts are served on four slider buns that have been baked together, giving you the option to eat it as one sandwich, or pull it apart into four sliders! House braised pulled pork, pickled vegetables, BBQ sauce, and cheddar cheese.

$12.00+

Käsekriner

House-made sausage made by our very own Matt the Butcher! Käsekrainer is a cheese sausage made with pork and swiss cheese. Served on a pretzel roll, with Düsseldorf mustard and grilled onions.

$10.00+

Vegan BBQ Jackfruit Sandwich

Braised jackfruit, pickled vegetables, Apple Serrano BBQ sauce, Teese Vegan Cheddar, Telera roll

$13.00+

Pie Slices

****Pie Slice Donation****

Every week we donate pie to medical workers and first responders! If you would like to add to our pie donations, simply add a Pie Donation Slice (or seven!) to your order!

$5.00

Banana Cream

Graham cracker crust, banana, whipped cream

$7.00

Chocolate Cream

Graham cracker crust, chocolate, whipped cream

$7.00

Coconut Cream

Graham cracker crust, coconut, whipped cream

$7.00

Key Lime Cream

Graham cracker crust, key lime, whipped cream

$7.00

Pistachio Cream

Graham cracker crust, pistachio, whipped cream

$7.00

Cherry (v)

Pastry crust, cherry, streusal topping

$6.00

Mixed Berry

Pastry crust, mixed berries, streusal topping

$6.00

Peach(v)

Pastry crust, peach, streusal topping

$6.00

Peach Blueberry

Pastry crust, peach, blueberry, streusal topping

$6.00

Whiskey Walnut Pecan

Pastry crust, whiskey, walnuts, pecans,

$6.00

Cookies and Cream

Oreo crumb crust, vanilla cream, whipped cream

$7.00

Salted Honey Pie

Pastry crust, rich salted honey center, whipped cream

$6.00

Cherry Apple

Pastry crust, cherry, apple, streusal topping

$6.00

Whole Pie

Whole pies are available on a limited basis each week, so get your orders in early! *****In some cases, Whole Pies will need to be ordered 24-48 hours in advance. If that is the case, and we cannot fill your order for the time you requested, we will contact you via your email and/or phone number. Whole pie orders filled in less than 24 hours will incur a $5 refundable pie tin deposit.****

Whole Chocolate Cream Pie

Graham cracker crust, chocolate, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Banana Cream Pie

Graham cracker crust, banana, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Pistachio Cream Pie

Graham cracker crust, pistachio, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Coconut Cream Pie

Graham cracker crust, coconut, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Key Lime Cream Pie

Graham cracker crust, key lime, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Cherry Pie (v)

Pastry crust, cherry, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Peach Pie (v)

Pastry crust, peach, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Blueberry Pie

Pastry crust, blueberry, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Peach Blueberry Pie

Pastry crust, peach, blueberry, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Mixed Berry Pie

Pastry crust, mixed berries, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Cookies and Cream Pie

Oreo crumb crust, vanilla cream, whipped cream

$40.00

Whole Salted Honey Pie

Pastry crust, rich salted honey center, whipped cream

$35.00

Whole Cherry Apple Pie

Pastry crust, cherry, apple, streusal topping

$35.00

Whole Whiskey Walnut Pecan Pie

Pastry crust, whiskey, walnuts, pecans

$35.00

Family Meals

Mac & Cheese Bake

Serves about 4-5. Just pick up and bake at home!

$25.00

Chili-Mac Bake

Serves about 4-5. Just pick up and bake at home!

$30.00

Extras

Side Of Serrano Peppers

$0.75

Side Of Giardiniera

$1.75

Drinks

Your cart is empty.